Our Favorite Gifts for 1- to 3-Year-Olds - Updated September 2019

Our Favorite Gifts for 1- to 3-Year-Olds

Finding the right gift for a toddler can be challenging. Everyone’s picking from the same tired roster of toys, often noisy, disposable ones that don’t hold a kid’s interest for long. We’ve given and received our share of successful gifts, as well as duds. All of our picks below are things the kids in our lives found fun and engaging long after the initial thrill of something new wore off—and were favorites of the adults in the home as well.

Regardless of what you choose, we highly recommend wrapping the present, even if it’s just in newspaper, because at this age, unwrapping often brings as much joy as what’s actually inside. And if you have more gift ideas, please share them in the comments.

If you’re looking for a gift for a slightly older kid, check out Our Favorite Gifts for 3- to 6-Year Olds and Our Favorite Gifts for 6- to 10-Year Olds.

Under $15

Everything’s better with eyes

Stick-on googly eyes can make just about anything more entertaining. While I often tuck sheets of these in with presents for other kids, my 2¾-year-old and I also like to use googly eyes to decorate those gifts. I start with a foundation of kraft paper, and Andie draws on it with markers or crayons, and then puts on these eyes, stickers, and washi tape. It’s very wabi sabi, and also a fun way to get the task done. I’ve bought individual adhesive googly eyes in bulk before, but the backing can be hard for even adults to remove. Andie can peel the Creativity Street Peel and Stick Wiggle Eyes off the sheet by herself, and the three sizes included in this pack are easy for a toddler to handle and to stick where she pleases. Note that these eyes could be a choking hazard; monitor your kids while they’re using them.

Textured tosser

Last update on 2019-09-20 PST - Details

Many toddlers go through a period of ball obsession, but the littlest kids can find regular soccer or playground balls difficult to grip or catch. When they were really young my kids loved colorful, grippy balls similar to these from Edushape or the Gertie Ball. The visiting friends who would throw or roll one back and forth with them dozens of times were a hit as well.

$15 to $50

A first piggy bank

Last update on 2019-09-20 PST - Details

My daughter received this toy piggy bank as a gift when she was 1, and as far as noisemaking plastic toys go, this one is a winner. Andie liked being rewarded with the pig’s cheerful responses and songs when she pressed its snout or dropped the large coins through the slot, and I liked how mercifully brief—and not too loud or grating—the songs and noises are. The pig helps with developing motor skills and teaches colors, counting (in Spanish, too!), and all that other important stuff. Now that Andie is nearly 3, she’s less interested in the pig, but it’s great for younger toddlers.

Not just for pretend tea

Sale Tolo Teatime Shape Sorter

Last update on 2019-09-19 PST - Details

I don’t think anyone passed through our house during my daughter’s toddler years without being coaxed into sitting for a colorful tea party with her and Tolo’s Teatime Shape Sorter. The teapot is sturdy and well-made, satisfyingly weighty, and easy for young children to carry. I know it can survive at least three years of consistent abuse from tiny hands. The clear plastic insert can be used with real liquids or removed completely so the teacups can slot in. It’s a fun alternative to the traditional shape sorters for littles, and a great first tea set.

A rainbow they can hold

Grimms Spiel und Holz makes beautifully crafted wooden stacking and puzzle toys that are as pleasing to look at as they are fun to play with. My 2-year-old niece loves to see their classic rainbow stacker in its fully assembled form and has endless fun taking it apart and imagining new uses for the individual pieces. So far we’ve used them as a belt, a phone, a hat, and a headband, and I have no doubt that we’ll continue to add to the list. Once playtime is over, you won’t mind seeing the rainbow stacker on your shelf. It’s such a lovely, cheery object that you may even opt to keep it there long after your child has outgrown stacking toys.

A classic hopper

Last update on 2019-09-20 PST - Details

Rody is a rounded, inflatable vinyl pony that’s perfect for a toddler who’s bouncing off the walls. My little kids loved to hop, scoot, and bump around the house on Rody, and because Rody is soft and springy, I loved not having to worry about them scuffing the floor or banging into walls. It’s hard not to smile at the pony’s cuddly shape, poppy colors, and cartoony-cuteness (it kind of looks like a Jeff Koons sculpture).

$50 and up

Three stories, endless role-playing

Last update on 2019-09-20 PST - Details

Hape’s three-story All Season House is bright, gender neutral, and open on all sides. My daughter loved that she could reach into any room from almost any spot to adjust the furniture and play with the wooden people (sold separately). I liked the extra furniture sets and accessories we could buy (like these pets). This was a staple toy during her toddler and preschool years, until we got a puppy who eventually devoured everything in the dollhouse, including the two families who lived there.

More Holiday & Gift Guides Reviews

The Best Things We Bought
Buying things may not lead you to happiness, but having the right stuff can make each day just a little[...]
The Best Things We Bought in 2018
Buying things may not lead you to happiness, but having the right stuff can make each day just a little[...]
The Best Holiday Cookie Baking Equipment and Gear
We spent 200 hours researching and tested 20 types of essential cookie-related items to find the best gear to make[...]
Great Boozy Holiday Gifts
Like a lot of people, I’ve given the gift of alcohol many times. Sometimes it’s the gift of last resort:[...]
Our Favorite Gifts for 6- to 10-Year-Olds
Finding a memorable gift for an elementary schooler can be challenging. Toy fads are hard to keep up with, often[...]
The Best Gear for Holiday Hosting
When family and friends arrive for longer stays, you’ll need a few extra supplies—especially if the spares you keep in[...]
Our Favorite Gifts for 3- to 6-Year-Olds
Our Favorite Gifts for 3- to 6-Year-Olds Kids between 3 and 6 often have clear and very vocal opinions about[...]
Our Favorite Gifts for 1- to 3-Year-Olds
Our Favorite Gifts for 1- to 3-Year-Olds Finding the right gift for a toddler can be challenging. Everyone’s picking from[...]
Our Favorite Tools for a Tricked-Out Halloween
Our Favorite Tools for a Tricked-Out Halloween If any holiday is about pure fun, it’s Halloween. Whether you’re looking to[...]
The Best Thanksgiving Kitchen Tools and Tableware
Whether you’re having a few pals over for Friendsgiving or an all-out, extended-family Thanksgiving feast, you’re probably going to need[...]
Great Gear for Picnics and Grilling
Charred burgers with all the fixings, ice-cold beer under a beach umbrella, toast with eggs scrambled over a campfire—food just[...]
The Holiday Gifts We’d Love to Give in 2018
Giving a gift is easy. Giving a gift that is well-received is much trickier. That’s why we’ve invited our staff[...]
Special Gifts for Your Favorite People
We at BeastsLive spend most of the year figuring out how to improve our readers lives with useful and thoughtful[...]
The Trick to Better Gifts: Thanks giving Snooping
The secret to masterful gifting is a little pre-holiday recon. When you’re visiting family and friends for Thanksgiving, take a[...]
The Gifts We Want to Give in 2018
All year long we focus on the best objective items—the practical and proven and most logical pieces of gear. The[...]

Leave a Comment